Видео

Spent a lot of time in Elite and X. Went to try what Star Citizen was turned into in the 10 years since I've bought it. Encountered a ton of bugs on a small run trying to get certified for delivery and quit. It's not a game, it's a way for Roberts to get even more cars while he sells pay-to-win ships with real money. More features sounds good until you realize that most of them don't work properly and the team is not fixing any of the old bugs.

19:14 sc starts to sweat lol

at least elite is a finished game.

Star Citizen is such a rubbish game, I can't believe it, This is 2024 we have Autoland and Autopilot systems in Planes, we have VFR and IFR maps to navigate to airports, in SC its 100s of years in the future, yet no Autodock or Autoland for space ships ? no map to any Spaceport? u fly at night in IMC conditions to arrive on a planet surface, then you have to go on RUclips or Reddit to ask hownto locate the spaceport? This is the most brainless space game ever. Total nonsense. Sorry, did I forget to mention no VR support? There is so much hype over nothing. Pls let no one compare this bug ridden pile of junk to Elite Dangerous. They are 1000s of intellectual years apart. SC is dumb and brainless. Thank u.

I tried star Citizen. Its just too unpolished and incomplete. I do agree it has more to offer, but, frontier seems to put more juice into the content they do have.

i would try star citizen. but i dont believe the game will ever release. 500 Million and the game still isnt out? idk seems fishy to me

I tried SC. It's for some cool stuff about it but Elite is well polished and feels like a complete game. So I just went back to it.

Crying about how large ships get stuck while using auto docker, and switching to Star Citizen. Is just silly. Star Citizen is just unplayable crap.

After 10 years and still useful

I can agree with your points, but I feel that each game does something better than the other. I do find the monetization of ED a bit better than SC, I mean a 48,000 microtransaction? and the game is still in early access? That's a pretty massive turn-off for me personally. As for the ship interior stuff, honestly I could care less. I care more about the flight and exploration than the extra tedium for the sake of immersion when it comes to this style of game. I might give SC a try when it fully releases, but so far I haven't heard too much good about it. Mostly I've heard it's a bunch of disjointed systems that don't mesh together very well. Of course I would need to try myself to make a final decision on it but again, that early access status plus enormous microtransaction options are just a big turnoff for me at the moment. Of course, the purpose of my comment isn't to tell you you're wrong. Everyone appreciates different things. And I'm not gonna go saying Frontier care about their players, I can like their game while acknowledging that they are a crap company, just like with any other game. I just wanted to provide another perspective is all. Either way, enjoy what you enjoy, that's why we play videogames after all.

It's said that elite is a mile long and only an inch wide.

А разрубить им что-то можно 🥸?

SOLD!

1500 hours into Elite dangerous... Stopped playing because i played on console... 😂

I've given up on Elite for all the reasons you listed. But I refuse to give Scam Citizen a dime. If it ever actually fully releases, and fulfills the promise that the outrageous pay-to-win will end, then I will jump in with both feet. But I genuinely believe that that will never happen. The feature creep and trend chasing will never end, because their business model isn't delivering a good game, it's delivering the dream of a good game. And if we're talking about lies from CEOs, Chris Roberts has given several release dates that CIG then blew past without a word. Not to mention they promised fifty hand-crafted star systems, and after over a decade they've delivered one. The only reason Chris Roberts doesn't have a long, long list of release feature promises broken is he hasn't actually released anything. I'm not saying don't play Star Citizen, if you enjoy it then you do you, just don't make more of it than it is.

I got Starcitizen but my PC was too shitty to play it. Plus, I just never understood the game mechanics. Too advanced for my Caveman ass.

so you exchange entire Galaxy for a single system game mostly FPS and nothing in behind. where is BGS in ED and Economy and where is it in SC, Two different games not commparable. I'm at 4,5k hours and stil not bored, space is wate and why do you think you must meet enybody 200ly from bubble at all

800 hours divided by probably £40 quid is 5p an hour. That sounds like unbelievable value for money 👍🏽

Too bad star citizen will never be finished.

I backed Star Citizen in 2012 and have been waiting over a decade now for something more than a dumpster fire, bug filled, proof of concept tech demo. I'd take a 40 dollar beta that gets ironed out over a few years than a multi hundred (and for some people thousand) dollar cash grab that feeds on hype for stretch goals and space pixels that haven't even come close to being touched by the devs in those now 12 years.

Those are some big tears you have rolling down your face. I notice almost no bugs and if I do see any they are minor. I have never ever seen an npc ship getting stuck in a mail slot, it has probably happened but I have never witnessed it. But hey enjoy Store Citizen, and your $48K DLC

It's only for Microsoft isn't it ? Yeah I'd love to play it but my laptop definitely isn't capable of running it , cant even play Elite on my laptop and I'm on ps5 . Pity , hate exclusivity with game

You should make a "Why I Ditched Star Citizen for Elite Dangerous 2024"

I would agree with you but I mean, as someone that thought he would help "find" that stupid Star Citizen many years ago and is still a freaking alpha, I find these statements starting regarding Star Citizen a joke... How much more freaking funding would it need to start shaping it into an actual game? I've contribute into the biggest gaming scum and promoting it into a video is just sad..

an explanation why you left one crappy sci-fi, space game dev team…. for another crappy space game dev team (that isn’t even a real game yet and is an obvious crowdfund scam that gives them more incentive to never finish the game than it does to actually finish it?) No thanks. Don’t even care to watch. Report on an actual game that exists and can replace either of these two lame excuses for game developers.

You've taken brief comments in a dev blog as a todo list.

elite is shite but so is SC sadly (business wise). can't trust either of these fucks. shame there's no other space games like these. maybe in 10 years.

Star citizen is crushed under its own feature creep. Im not joining it sorry

you fell for it, that's why.

In Star Citizen, I can wake up, go down an elevator, take a train, take an elevator, re-buy all my shit, take an elevator, recall my ship, take an elevator, enter my ship, fly to a mission location, land on the planet, WALK ON THE PLANET AND FIGHT DUDES, then fall through the geometry and die. In Elite Dangerous, I spawn into my ship and die because I was careless, not because the game is buggy.

I’m sorry to say this, but I’d ditch Elite Dangerous even for Minesweeper after all the bad DLCs and the ‘we don’t give a f***’ mentality from Frontier Developments

The current state of ED makes me sad but I just can't get into SC. SC feels like it wants to do what ED can't but that's about it to me

I still love and play Elite Dangerous, as well as Star Citizen and Spacebourne 2,love them all. It's freaking X4 I don't get and it was suggested by a friend to play instead of SC

I want to play star citizen but I can't because I don't have a PC for it it would be awesome if it could be a console game too

669,000,000$ is how much they have made so far..... i think we need to stop the copium...

I always find it funny when I see videos like these. The whole "Why I left" or "Why I swapped to X" thing always seems like its the creator trying to justify to themselves why they switched, when realistically, no one cares. play what you wanna play, you don't need to explain s**t to anyone.

Star Citizens main issues: 1) You work hard, make money, buy ships... with the next alpha update you loose everything 2) No VR

all that money. all those backers. games still shit. imagine.

Awesome video. Frontier have always been the same by the way. I'm old enough to have played the original elite when it was on the BBC micro. Through the years they have pushed out super promising games that have not maybe met their promises or have been bug ridden, etc. I feel genuinely sad every time I look at the potential the game still has vs the realisation of that potential from the developers. I haven't been that interested in Star Citizen to date but the more I look at it recently, the more I want to jump in, it's really taking shape. Once again, thanks for the video.

But you have no videos of Elite whatsoever...think someone is rage baiting

Just tried Elite today as a Star Citizen Veteran, although I understand your frustration about Elite, there are some aspects in Elite I'm quite fond of, such as the freedom to outfit your ships to suit different roles and needs, powerplay with galactic news and lore, and the sheer amount of systems to travel and chart. I myself as a developer do believe that it always come down to the budget of the company that determine which and how well certain features can be implemented into games. It's all just different developers using what they have at hands to make most achievable attempts. And Cig as a very unusual example, have been quite fortunate, and also dedicate, to have come this far.

Face it. For all its critics, Elite as the paradigm and ED specifically is the boss of space sims. SC came much later (and it's STILL unfinished) just copied the best parts of ED and then built upon the rest. Elite led the innovation. SC is just an improved copy.

This is a weird hill to die on... Especially in favor of a whale farm vaporware that will never release.

I went the other way... Star Citizen 1st, and now on ED. SC is a great tech demo, but it's not a game, yet.

So you support a game that's made far more sales and money but hasn't even been released in the 13 years of development... doesn't make sense to me. Are you a backer? Probably most people know star citizen is nothing but money laundering

I left ED a few years back before Odyssey and started SC. Bought several nice ships in SC, mostly mining and trading. SC ran my old 2070 super pretty hot- SC needs more cpu/gpu than ED and 30xx up is not a budget priority. Bought a virpil constellation for SC then took a pause. The bugs in SC are freaking annoying... Last 6 months went back to ED. 2nd joystick, lots of fun. Haz res etc. Into the black 22k LY, ground the creds for a fleet carrier. Whole new game opened up. I keep an eye on SC, which seems to be improving patch by patch. I'll keep on with ED as its really fun, loads of game loops, game is stable. I'll drop back to SC when the next pc upgrade comes around. Both great games. SC has so much potential. Love space either way. O7

The shouldnt of stopped on conceals they dragged there feet and got too lazy and it was a blow too them and lost alot of comanders content creators hugh amount of players left they keep dropping the ball and losing money because of there laziness they still can make this a epic game but there heads up there asses

You lost me when you said you purchased ships to support developers so that they can reach their goals… they are sitting on over 600 million wtf is wrong with you??? Both games have their problems but SC has like 5% of content of ED and the eye candy is included in it.

Star citizen has the most complicated controls set up I have ever encountered. Wtaf.

CiG doesn't care about player experience but they do care about taking your money. It's a fundraiser not a game.